साक्षात्-तुलनाIndependent residual reproduction
sākṣāt-tulanā
Run the published bench against your own DE441 build. We publish the 1,000-date × 9-graha test set; you publish your residuals. If they reproduce ours within noise, we cite each other.
peer-review surface · cc by 4.0 · agpl · refutation invited
Bharat Ephemeris is a research artifact with a seeker-facing surface — not the reverse. Everything is reviewable: the substrate paper and reproducible proof scripts in the published Zenodo deposit, quarterly residual reports, machine-checked propositions. Scholars are invited to refute us.
Published: DOI 10.5281/zenodo.20024273 (v3 · 230 propositions · 83/83 machine-checked · 2026-05-04). Current internal catalog: 890 propositions · 805/805 machine-checked — APEX v5/v6, publication pending. The internal numbers are not yet covered by the cited DOI and are stated here only as work-in-progress.
Two separate claims, two separate proofs. The ephemeris accuracy claim — Sun 0.13′ p95 / 0.21′ max, Moon 0.51′ p95 / 1.0′ max, all nine grahas ≤ 3.3′ max across 1,000 samples spanning 2000–2050 — is an empirical measurement of Sūrya-Siddhānta + Kerala-school + dṛk computation against NASA/JPL Horizons, reproducible via scripts/audit/. The (R, g, k) substrate is a separate algebraic research program in number theory with its own DOI. Planetary longitudes do not derive from modular arithmetic, and this site does not claim they do.
| artifact | detail | tier | access |
|---|---|---|---|
| साधार-दत्तम्(R, g, k) algebraic substrate — published record | DOI 10.5281/zenodo.20024273 (v3 · 230 propositions · 83/83 machine-checked · 2026-05-04) | Tier-S | doi.org → |
| मूल-लिपिःProof scripts — bundled in the same Zenodo deposit | Reproducible proof scripts archived inside DOI 10.5281/zenodo.20024273 · CC BY 4.0 | Tier-S | doi.org → |
| तुलना-दर्शनम्Accuracy audit — Bharat vs NASA/JPL Horizons | 1,000-date × 9-graha bake-off · 50-year span · Tier-S/W per graha | Tier-S | /accuracy → |
| तुलनम्Compare table — 38 platforms · 4 ground-truth observatories | Structural rigour vs prediction-shaped · feature parity audit | Tier-W | /compare → |
The mathematics this engine runs on was not borrowed late. It was written down in Bhārata first — in some cases by a margin of centuries, in one case by a margin of millennia. Each row below is a claim about surviving documents, and each carries a citation you can pull from any research library.
| result | Bhāratīya locus | usually credited | lead |
|---|---|---|---|
| मात्रा-मेरुःThe Fibonacci recursion | Piṅgala, Chandaḥśāstra — enumeration of mātrā metres · c. 300–200 BCE (dating debated); the recursion is stated explicitly by Virahāṅka (c. 600–800 CE) and Hemacandra (1150 CE)1,2 | Leonardo of Pisa (Fibonacci), Liber Abaci · 1202 CE | ≈ 1,400 yr |
| मेरु-प्रस्तारःThe binomial triangle | Piṅgala's prastāra (combinatorial enumeration of metres); the triangle itself set out in Halāyudha's Mṛtasañjīvanī commentary · 10th c. CE2 | Pascal, Traité du triangle arithmétique · 1665 CE | ≈ 700 yr |
| अनन्त-श्रेणीInfinite series for π, sine and cosine | Mādhava of Saṅgamagrāma (c. 1340–1425), transmitted through Nīlakaṇṭha's Tantrasaṅgraha (1501) and Jyeṣṭhadeva's Yuktibhāṣā (c. 1530) — with error terms and convergence accelerators3,4,5 | Newton (c. 1669) · Gregory (1671) · Leibniz (1673) | ≈ 250–300 yr |
| अष्टाध्यायीFormal generative grammar with metarules | Pāṇini, Aṣṭādhyāyī · c. 5th c. BCE — ~4,000 ordered sūtras, a technical metalanguage, paribhāṣā metarules, and explicit conflict resolution (vipratiṣedha, 1.4.2)6,7 | Backus–Naur Form · 1959–1963 CE | ≈ 2,400 yr |
| आर्यभटीयम्Diurnal rotation · sine table · decimal place-value | Āryabhaṭa, Āryabhaṭīya · 499 CE — the earth's rotation producing the apparent westward motion of the stars (Gola 9), a 24-entry jyā table in steps of 3°45′ (Gaṇita 12), π ≈ 3.1416 explicitly labelled āsanna, “approaching” (Gaṇita 10), all inside a fully positional decimal framework8 | Rotation: Copernicus · 1543 CE. Place-value into Europe: Liber Abaci · 1202 CE | ≈ 700–1,000 yr |
| तात्कालिक-गतिःInstantaneous rate of change | Bhāskara II, Siddhānta-Śiromaṇi · 1150 CE — tātkālika-gati distinguished from mean motion, the sine differential, and the observation that the instantaneous rate vanishes where the planet is stationary (a Rolle-type statement)9,10 | Rolle · 1691 CE; Newton and Leibniz · c. 1665–1675 CE | ≈ 500 yr |
Not as homage — as usage. The Kerala-school series in the kernel are the same mathematics: Nīlakaṇṭha’s equation-of-centre and śīghra corrections from the Tantrasaṅgraha (1501) are evaluated directly, and Mādhava’s periodic terms are the terms we sum. We did not rediscover this material from a European textbook and then decorate it with Sanskrit names. We compute with the series as the paramparā wrote them, and we measure the result against NASA/JPL Horizons in public.
What this section does not claim. (a) That any of these results reached Europe. Independent rediscovery versus transmission is an open historiographical question, and nothing above depends on the answer. (b) That Backus or Naur read Pāṇini — the kinship is structural, and it was later computer scientists who noted it. (c) That historical priority is evidence of this engine’s accuracy. Priority is settled by manuscripts; accuracy is settled by residuals, measured against NASA/JPL Horizons and published on /accuracy.
sākṣāt-tulanā
Run the published bench against your own DE441 build. We publish the 1,000-date × 9-graha test set; you publish your residuals. If they reproduce ours within noise, we cite each other.
grantha-samīkṣā
If you publish on BPHS, Sārāvalī, Phaladīpikā, Jaimini-Sūtra and your edition meets the citation discipline (ISBN + translator + page), we link readers from /library to your publication; you cite the (R, g, k) substrate.
daśā-prastāva
We currently route 12 daśā systems. If your paramparā computes a 13th — a regional Vimśottarī variant, for instance — submit a PR or paper. We bench it, route it, and credit you on the new /dasha/[system] page.
megha-gaṇanam
Joint sprint to take Candra from the current ~1 arc-minute (p95 0.51′) vs NASA/JPL Horizons toward arc-second precision — by extending the indigenous Kerala-school series (additional Mādhava / Tantrasaṅgraha periodic terms: evection, variation, annual equation), 100% Bhāratīya, zero foreign runtime. Co-publish, named co-authorship, open-source release.
Send your CV or publication list and the track you want to enter. The verified-academic API tier is ₹0, permanently.
(R, g, k) = (ℤ/3³³⁷ℤ, 2, k=337) · published: DOI 10.5281/zenodo.20024273 (v3 · 230 propositions · 83/83 machine-checked) · internal catalog: 890 propositions · 805/805 — APEX v5/v6, publication pending